This is a big one. It was extremely difficult to frame a complete answer to all the parts of this question.
To understand what I mean, play the video below and listen closely at the full question as I read it. You’ll no doubt recognize it’s broad implications. Nevertheless, I feel like I touched upon the most important factors and provided some concrete examples as to why I have drawn certain conclusions.
Hope you enjoy.
Keep in mind that the examples I cite in the video only hint at the broader spectrum of changes that have occurred. Each style and system has it’s own tale to tell.
Check out question 5 – Are Traditional Martial Arts Too Rigid?
The globalization of martial arts is still a young phenomenon. Think back only a few generations and you’ll notice that each particular art was mostly relegated to it’s birth country, with just a few foreign practitioners modestly spreading it back in their home countries.
Nowadays, any town that doesn’t offer at least three different kinds of arts is considered modest in size.
With this accelerated spread we’ve encountered a handful of problems that our predecessors wouldn’t have had to consider; one of which is the inclusion of ‘home language’. Some martial arts schools choose to do away with it entirely, while others prefer to preserve it.
In today’s video, I weigh the value of preserving your art’s origin language and when it might not be appropriate to do so:
Whether or not you choose to include an origin language in your studies, I hope you do it purposefully (knowing what you are gaining and losing).
Check out question 4 – What Martial Art Methods and Values Have Been Lost in Modern Times?
Our first question revolves around a very classic problem in traditional arts – do people actually use kata during sparring?
Part of the inefficient, ritualized stereotype that goes along with traditional arts stems directly from this issue. Furthermore, when watching sparring at any tournament or even online you are likely to see a grand total of zero exchanges that look like kata.
Check out my perspective on the matter:
The cut-to video utilized in the video above is from a previous post entitled Exploring the Value of Nai Hanchi. Check out the full post if you are interested in a more specific study of this kata/application/combat type question.
Hope you enjoyed it, and check out question 2 – What Kind of Grappling Is In Karate?