homeikigai shop and ebooksmartial artsinterviewsaboutcontact

Don’t Wear Martial Arts On Your Sleeve

March 26, 2009 | Author: Matthew | Filed under: Martial Arts,Opinion,Philisophical,Tips and Tricks,mindset

This is a story. Once upon a time there was a karate student. The student trained hard and ultimately passed his Shodan black belt examination. Upon returning home from the dojo he threw a large party and invited all his friends, family, and neighbors.

Some years later the same student passed his Nidan black belt examination. Upon returning home from the dojo he hugged his family, called a few close friends, and had a drink in celebration.

Years after that the student passed his Sandan black belt examination. Upon leaving the dojo he quietly slipped his belt and certificates into his bag and walked home, making no effort to draw attention to himself.

Here’s another story. William Dometrich was the first non-asian student to study under the renowned karate expert Tsuyoshi Chitose of the Chito-Ryu. Dometrich Sensei flourished as a karateka and after his tour of military duty was over he returned to America as a Sandan. While Dometrich Sensei was trying to establish the first United States Chito-Ryu Karate Federation, Chitose Sensei sent him his Yondan rank, which Dometrich Sensei reluctantly accepted with great humility and gratitude.

After a few more years of teaching and building his federation, Dometrich Sensei received word from Chitose Sensei that he was to be promoted to Godan. A week later his certificates arrived in the mail. So aghast by this and overcome by his feelings of inadequacy for such a rank, Dometrich Sensei attempted to hide the certificates in his sock drawer. If it weren’t for the subtle unveiling of the rank by his wife Barbara a few months later, no one would have known about the promotion.

The Difference Between Sharing and Gloating

At one point or another we’ve all felt that rush of enthusiasm regarding martial arts. We want to talk people’s heads off, show them crazy new techniques, and discuss the intricacies of what makes our art so great. This is completely normal and is actually a good sign that martial arts are becoming a valued part of daily life.

As time goes by, this enthusiasm can transform into two different things – quiet determination or loud ego stroking.

In the first story above, the karateka initially wishes to share his success and hard work with everyone around him (which is only natural). As his training continues, he begins to learn about the core concepts that make martial arts what they are – humility, dignity, justice, courage. He starts to realize that flamboyant displays stand in stark contrast with these qualities. Furthermore, he becomes better acquainted with the higher ranking members of his school and federation, which in turn shows him how far he has to go. Ultimately, the black belt runs into the stark realization that he is not a  master, and that if he wants to excel, he needs to quiet down and get to work.

On the other hand – martial arts rank and achievement can give practitioners a taste of success and power that feels so good they wish to reproduce it whenever possible. This kind of person finds excuses to talk about their success. They wear karate t-shirts, talk about fighting or ufc or some such, and quietly hope they can find a way to turn any conversation toward something they’ve accomplished.

Keep it Low Key For Self Defense Purposes

Martial arts arrogance isn’t just annoying – it can actually be dangerous! One of the primary goals of martial arts is to improve your ability to defend yourself, and part of that is the art of deception and posturing. Body language is a huge part of social interaction, and one of the key principles for self defense is not appearing like a victim. To do that, you have to exude a sense of confidence and self assuredness. But, if you go too far and start appearing arrogant and puffy chested, you’ll be just as certain to attract problems.

Troublemakers of the world are looking for two kinds of people – weaklings they can harass, and people they can hammer down because ‘they think they’re so great’. By being very conscious of your demeanor you can avoid both of these stigmas.

Keep it Low Key For Dignity Purposes

There is one thing I’ve come to learn – real martial artists can size each other up within minutes. Body language, movement, eye contact, demeanor, conversation topics…it’s all so subtle and yet so telling. Think of it this way – when you first started learning how to spar, you probably used big movements and techniques right? But, as you progress, you learn how to control center line and conserve motion, thus allowing you to counter attack with speed and fluidity. Character is the same way.

People who’s personalities seem to entail large strokes are like the white belt beginners and are generally mildly tolerated by martial artists who have learned better. The Japanese as a culture (and in the business realm) are famous for this kind of subtlety and it is just as important within martial arts. An expert martial artist will let you reveal your flaws to him, just as if you were over extending a punch.

Literally – Don’t Wear Martial Arts on Your Sleeve

Analysis and philosophy aside, you shouldn’t wear obnoxious martial arts attire because it can make you look stupid.

Seriously – this stuff is lame sauce. If you’re promoting something like Livestrong that has a purpose, then I understand. But no one cares about your MMA or black belt status. The best possible scenario here is if someone punches you in the face and says “why didn’t you block it mr. black belt?”

There is a Time and a Place

Blogging…teaching at the dojo…a dinner with fellow students…these are all healthy ways to get martial arts energies out. They are appropriate because you aren’t forcing yourself on anyone – it’s understood that martial arts will be discussed. Even still, in those situations we have to be careful how much we talk about ourselves and not the art itself. It’s a fine line. If you aren’t sure if you’re an offender, just take note of other people that clearly cross the line and make sure you aren’t doing the same thing. In the long run, you’ll find martial arts conversation much more meaningful when nothing is forced or based on bravado.

Related Posts with Thumbnails
Share This (Good Karma Guaranteed):
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • StumbleUpon
  • Digg
  • Technorati
xygoxen
  • I agree completely! Anyone who has trained long enough to truly have earned a Dan rank should know better than to make a public display of it. That goes against the mental dicipline that is suppose to be the bedrock of traditional martial arts. And, in many circles, is just asking for trouble as well. Everyone, sometimes, seems to want to "be the Man that beat the Man"!

    http://actionkaratearts.com/why-we-train/should...
  • bloodisredsweat
    I am new to this site and I really enjoy the articles posted here, i just have a question regarding this article. does anyone here think that its wrong to talk about your martial arts in public, with people that also train in the martial arts?
    like, say im having a conversation, with someone that trains in martial arts, but around other people? because me and my friends who train in various martial arts like to discuss our training, the differences ect. but this generally takes place out in public amongst other people.
  • Hey red, thanks for stopping by! I appreciate your visit. I can only speak for my personal opinion, and others can chime in as well, but I believe that the scenario you've set out is not inappropriate.

    If you are out in public and you are speaking to friends and other martial artists, it really is of no concern to other people nearby. It's not like you are grabbing strangers by the sleeve and forcing them to listen to you. If they choose to eavesdrop then that would be their choice.

    Certainly there are some risque topics that are not public appropriate, but I don't think this is one of them.
  • bloodisredsweat
    thanks for the welcome and quick response matt. i have already tabbed this site for a homepage and look forward to reading further informative posts such as this and the others on the site. thanks for the help.
  • Hi! Just found your blog, and am enjoying your archives. Most of my martial-arts t-shirts are from seminars, except one I got from Cafe Press that just tickles me no end: "Warning: throws like a girl"

    I once had a massage therapist at a spa, before even laying hands on me, ask if I did yoga. When I responded no, but I practice Aikido, she said that she could tell from my posture that I did some kind of physical discipline. So, your training may be apparent to those who know how to look, whether you consciously project it or not. And it may affect the impressions of others who don't consciously realize what they are picking up on.
  • Haha, yea I think you get a pass on the cafe press shirt - that is funny!
  • Good post. I feel like a lot of schools today perpetuate this problem. The whole 'black belt club' mcdojo mentality I think is one of the greatest causes.

    Looks like you're into Kyusho too - have we met?
  • Great post.

    I proudly display my certificates, and the few trophies I have, in my home office, as I'm quite proud of my accomplishments. Anyone in my home would already know about my hobbies, anyone that didn't, it simply makes for fun conversation.

    I keep a mug in my office for pens that says "Ip Ching Wing Chun" on it. I've vacillated on keeping it here, but the reason I have it in the first place is that I'm always on the look out for new martial friends and work out partners. I don't think there's anything wrong with telling people what your interests are (I also have a few D&D minis).

    So I think you're absolutely correct when you say "Don’t Wear Martial Arts On Your Sleeve", but that doesn't mean don't wear it at all.

    Balance is the key to all things.
  • Good article. I had an instructor give me a nice jacket one year with "Sensei" sewn on. To be honest I'd never wear it out, except to the dojo or visiting my mother. (Do you have that "Arrogant" shirt in XL?)
  • Ed R.
    Good words to follow.
  • Adam: Yea that's almost something you have to learn the hard way. Sooner or later being too vocal about martial arts will backfire and you'll be a little more cautious after that, haha.

    Elias: Don't worry - there are times when I can't help myself either, haha.
  • Hmmm I guess I'm still at the age/level where I just can't control my enthusiasm... Srsly.

    On the other hand, most people who know me (unless they facebook stalk me) don't even know about my Krav... But it's partly cause I don't want someone to say "disarm this!!" and whack me with some sort of stick...
  • Great post Matthew!

    Now that im older (but still young and young at heart!) there are many people I work with or know who don't even know I practise martial arts. Its more of a personal thing for me now.

    Its something I take seriously but I feel no need to tell people all about it. If it comes up in conversation, for sure, I will contribute but other than that, I just do my own thing and plod along.

    Again, really nice post.
  • Chris: Yea false humility can be very obvious - like you said, hollywood humble.

    Sensei Strange: Thanks for stopping by!
  • Great blog!
  • ...One who adopts the outward signs of humility may be nominally "virtuous", but in the end they are just manipulating and role-playing, same as the braggart.

    Nobody is humble when they are training alone in the forest, for example. The concept is irrelevant in such circumstances. On the scale of self-cultivation, I rank sincerity higher than humility.
  • Chris: Do you mean when a person tell tales of bravado and humility about themselves, or like when I told stories about others in my post?


    Either way. I enjoy "talking shop" with people I know and trust, I just wouldn't do it in mixed company. None of the masters I've known were "Hollywood humble" and obviously neither am I. :)
  • Jon: Yea it's amazing what a mixture of confidence and intelligence can do! Those are some of the less noted benefits of martial arts training.

    Eric: I'm gonna make an exception for you. Please feel free to pimp out your gear as much as you want.
  • Massimo: That's a great example, thank you for sharing that! Certainly that student of yours could have written this post even better than I because he experienced it first hand.

    Krista: Your post is an excellent one. I recommend to anyone who has a few spare minutes.

    Sean: Very true. I didn't touch upon that too much in the post.

    MAM: Don't worry - I do the same thing! haha. This post is a self warning as much as anything else because sometimes I can't help myself either.
  • Eric M
    Nice post, but I guess this means when I get home tonight I will have to get rid of all my t-shirts, pants, shirts, shorts, boxers, jackets, baseball caps, wrist bands, jewelry, key chains, notebooks, pens, bumper stickers, and novelty license plate (Did I miss anything?) that all have martial arts related stuff printed on them. The garbage man is going to have his hands full.

    Seriously though, the only time I tend to make my martial arts training known in public, that I'm aware of, is when I'm on vacation at the beach. I usually wear my uniform just so anybody who happens to see me doing kata doesn't think I'm just some crazy guy fighting off figments of his imagination (even though that's what I'm actually trying to do). I also make sure I'm on the beach early in the mornings when most potential trouble makers are still sleeping off their hangovers from the night before. One time I did have the beach patrol watching me from a distance in their SUV. They never approached me. Other than that, whenever someone walking along the beach happened to pass by me, we just exchanged friendly greetings, and they continued on their way.
  • I think the straying from expressing your enthusiasm is a natural progression. When I first started training I couldn't help myself.

    I do display my certificates at home, but not overtly. Shodan in my bedroom, sandan in the living room, but not obvious. The one on display the most is my first certificate, which is there to mark the start.

    I do have tattoo's that represent my progress, but they are of koi, so not obvious. I like to keep it discrete but if people ask me, it can spill out like an avalanche!

    On my blog I generally keep everything anonymous other than my teachers past and present.

    In terms of self-protection, delivering a surprise to an attacker is always useful but the confidence you mention works time after time for me. A short while after beginning karate I adopted a motto "I refuse to be intimidated" and it works most of the time. Usually those wanting a fight are cowards, unless you stumble upon the wrong un.........
  • I agree with you 100% but I also have to admit that the "geek" in me is so proud of the fact that I actually practice martial arts, I want to shout it from the rooftops. LOL Seriously, it is something I am so proud of - matter of fact that of which I'm the MOST proud of besides my kids - so I have to rein it in sometimes. But I try to keep my intense enthusiasm in check except for with those whom I share class. Great post!
  • Sean C. Ledig
    Great post. But I think a martial artist also has an obligation to avoid situations where it's likely he'll have to defend himself.

    For example, many people assume I don't drink for religious or health reasons. The truth is, is that people get obnoxious and arrogant when they drink. By not drinking myself and avoiding social situations where drinking is the main activity, I avoid a lot of trouble.
  • Great Post.

    I agree that in the West there seems to be far too much focus on rank and grades - a topic I also recently wrote a post about.

    I think the point you're making about self defense is an important one too. I know that when our club goes out occasionally for drinks or to watch a professional fight Sensei is sure to remind us to use his first name. A good way to avoid attracting any unwanted attention, but loosing the "Sensei" is a hard habit to break.
  • I am in total agreement with you about keeping it low key is a great way of avoiding troubles. A student of mine, now black belt, used to wear his black trousers, with a big "KICKBOXING" written on the full length of one leg, while walking home after training and he got picked and abused a number of times... then he learnt. At the same time I can see why, in your story at the beginning, the student throws a big party when he achieves his Nidan: the first time you make it to black belt is great sense of achievement and you want to party. Getting older and mature you understand that the progress in martial arts is your personal journey and it's no point shouting it about. Black belt is not an end but a beginning of a new journey.
  • Chris: Do you mean when a person tell tales of bravado and humility about themselves, or like when I told stories about others in my post?

    If you're talking about me telling stories about others, then yes - certainly I could tell some dingers and it would be entertaining.

    But if you are talking about people telling stories about themselves, I'm not sure one could actually tell an astounding story of self humility. It would kinda take the humility out of it. You know? haha.
  • Bob: Totally right - there are certainly degrees. I have karate stuff floating around my place too. I definitely went the archetype route to help make the point.

    That's really funny about the email regarding your injury. There's a person who took my point way too seriously, hahaha.

    Vic: Nicely said. And that's a great cover with the bonsai society.
  • I never wear crests that contain any words that could be interpreted as a martial art logo.Used to have one that had a pine tree on it and some letters an acronym .
    When someone would ask me what it was I would say "It's a bonsai society".In the oral tradition there is a statement about kamae or posture inviting danger.Posture is more than how you present yourelf to the world.

    vic
  • Great post!

    I think there are degrees in what one is comfortable with and that depends on the individual. The archetype you describe is literally a MA idiot and we've all seen that type of person.

    e.g. my last TKD instructor refuses to display her belts, trophies, etc. She has them packed all away in a closet and the only thing she does display is a gift from me and one from her past master. I asked her why and she shrugged and just said: "Some day I can show my daughter what mommy did."

    I on the other hand am a little more aggressive. Let's face it: Getting 1st dan done at 40 tore me up. Three ER visits with possible broken feet, one cracked rib, etc. So HELL yeah after retiring from TKD I PROUDLY display my belts and trophies in my home office! In fact, if you look carefully you can see a little blood on one of those belts. I earned it and there they will proudly hang!

    Funny but I had one person e-mail me recently and suggest I should not blog about my injury. The gist of what they said is I'm revealing a weakness which is tactically bad. My response was essentially: "What, the Ninja community has a warrant out on Bob Patterson?" I love the martial arts and am a enthusiast for sure but I am not a professional fighter, nor am I Batman, so I suspect I'll be OK. In fact blogging about it helped me NOT to worry as much.

    -B
  • Personally, I enjoy tales of bravado just as much as tales of humility, if not more so.

    I agree about the shirts. Nobody really deserves to get beaten up, but maybe these folks deserve it a little bit? ;)

    We also talked about belt shirts at
    http://www.stevebjj.com/2008/12/early-christmas...
  • definitely good thoughts on the martial arts. it definitely is amusing at how one's perspective on things changes the longer one is in the martial arts and becomes more engrossed in "the way" of the martial arts.
blog comments powered by Disqus